For reviewers

How to Evaluate

Pharmaceutical Sciences and Health Products uses double-blind external peer review. Reviewer identities are not disclosed to authors. Suitable manuscripts are evaluated by at least two independent external reviewers. Recommendations are advisory; the handling editor and, where required, the Editor-in-Chief make the final decision.

Structured assessment

The online form covers scope and originality, study design, methods, ethics and safety, data quality, analysis and validation, results, interpretation, reporting, presentation and research integrity. Each applicable criterion is marked as Meets requirements, Minor concern, Major concern or Not applicable.

Scientific priorities

  • Clear research question and an appropriate study design.
  • Reproducible methods, adequate controls or comparators and transparent quality-control procedures.
  • Appropriate ethics, safety and registration information where applicable.
  • Valid analytical, statistical or computational methods with suitable validation.
  • Results that are complete, internally consistent and proportionate to the claims.
  • Transparent limitations, uncertainty, data/code availability and sponsor involvement.
  • Compliance with the reporting guideline or technical standard appropriate to the study type.

Comments to authors

Begin with a concise summary of the manuscript and its principal strengths. Number major and minor comments. Identify the exact section, table, figure or supplementary file concerned. Explain why each requested change matters and distinguish essential revisions from optional suggestions.

Confidential comments to the editor

Use this field for conflicts, suspected misconduct, concerns about anonymization, doubts about data reliability, reasons for rejection that should not be disclosed immediately, or advice on specialist review. Do not contradict the substantive comments sent to authors without explanation.