For reviewers

Recommendations

Pharmaceutical Sciences and Health Products uses double-blind external peer review. Reviewer identities are not disclosed to authors. Suitable manuscripts are evaluated by at least two independent external reviewers. Recommendations are advisory; the handling editor and, where required, the Editor-in-Chief make the final decision.

Accept

Suitable for publication without substantive scientific changes.

Minor Revision

Limited changes are required and the core design, data and conclusions remain sound.

Major Revision

Substantial but potentially feasible changes are required before the manuscript can be reconsidered.

Reject and Resubmit

The manuscript requires a fundamental redesign or new analysis and should return as a new submission if the authors undertake that work.

Reject

The manuscript has fundamental scope, methodological, ethical, reporting or integrity problems that cannot be addressed through revision.

Advisory status

Your recommendation is one element of the editorial decision. Editors may reach a different decision after considering all reports, methodological priorities, journal scope, ethics and the authors’ responses.