Journal policy
Peer Review Policy
Every scholarly manuscript undergoes double-blind external peer review by at least two independent reviewers before an acceptance decision.
Scope of peer review
PSHP publishes original research, reviews, systematic reviews and meta-analyses, methods, technology, clinical, regulatory, health-economic and other scholarly article types across pharmaceutical sciences and health products. Scholarly submissions are subject to external peer review unless explicitly designated as editorial record-maintenance material.
- At least two external and independent reviewers are required before an acceptance decision for peer-reviewed scholarly articles.
- The anonymized manuscript and relevant supplementary materials are made available to reviewers only after they accept the invitation and declarations.
Double-blind model
Reviewer identities are not disclosed to authors, and reviewers do not receive the separate author-identifying title page during ordinary review. The handling editor and authorized editorial staff know the identities needed to administer the process and manage conflicts.
- Reviewer reports are transmitted to authors without reviewer names.
- Reviewer reports are not published and reviewers do not sign comments to authors.
- Reviewers do not see the identities or reports of other reviewers unless the editor determines that a controlled consultation is necessary.
Editorial assessment and reviewer selection
- The Editorial Office performs a technical check before academic assessment.
- A handling editor assesses scope, reporting completeness, ethics/registration information where applicable, conflicts and basic methodological suitability.
- Reviewers are selected for relevant expertise, independence, availability and workload.
- Reviewers must disclose financial, collaborative, supervisory, institutional, personal and other conflicts before accepting.
- Editors may seek a third review when reports materially conflict or specialist expertise is missing.
Exact exceptions
The following non-scholarly record-maintenance items do not undergo the ordinary two-reviewer process: Correction, Retraction, Expression of Concern, Publisher Notice, Editorial Notice and administrative journal announcements. They receive appropriate editorial and, where needed, legal or research-integrity review. Letters to the Editor receive editorial assessment and may be externally reviewed when they contain substantial methodological analysis, new calculations or allegations requiring specialist assessment.
Timelines and records
- The response and review due dates are stated in each individual reviewer invitation and secure portal.
- The journal records invitations, responses, reminders, extensions, reports, decisions and recusals in the secure editorial system.
- Authors are informed when unusual delay materially affects processing.
Questions or concerns
Use the appropriate secure route when a matter requires a documented response.