Journal policy

Peer Review Policy

Every scholarly manuscript undergoes double-blind external peer review by at least two independent reviewers before an acceptance decision.

Scope of peer review

PSHP publishes original research, reviews, systematic reviews and meta-analyses, methods, technology, clinical, regulatory, health-economic and other scholarly article types across pharmaceutical sciences and health products. Scholarly submissions are subject to external peer review unless explicitly designated as editorial record-maintenance material.

  • At least two external and independent reviewers are required before an acceptance decision for peer-reviewed scholarly articles.
  • The anonymized manuscript and relevant supplementary materials are made available to reviewers only after they accept the invitation and declarations.

Double-blind model

Reviewer identities are not disclosed to authors, and reviewers do not receive the separate author-identifying title page during ordinary review. The handling editor and authorized editorial staff know the identities needed to administer the process and manage conflicts.

  • Reviewer reports are transmitted to authors without reviewer names.
  • Reviewer reports are not published and reviewers do not sign comments to authors.
  • Reviewers do not see the identities or reports of other reviewers unless the editor determines that a controlled consultation is necessary.

Editorial assessment and reviewer selection

  • The Editorial Office performs a technical check before academic assessment.
  • A handling editor assesses scope, reporting completeness, ethics/registration information where applicable, conflicts and basic methodological suitability.
  • Reviewers are selected for relevant expertise, independence, availability and workload.
  • Reviewers must disclose financial, collaborative, supervisory, institutional, personal and other conflicts before accepting.
  • Editors may seek a third review when reports materially conflict or specialist expertise is missing.

Decision authority

Reviewer recommendations are advisory. The handling editor evaluates the manuscript, all reports, author responses and journal policies. The Editor-in-Chief may review disputed, high-risk or integrity-related cases. Acceptance cannot be issued until the minimum independent-review requirement is met.

Exact exceptions

The following non-scholarly record-maintenance items do not undergo the ordinary two-reviewer process: Correction, Retraction, Expression of Concern, Publisher Notice, Editorial Notice and administrative journal announcements. They receive appropriate editorial and, where needed, legal or research-integrity review. Letters to the Editor receive editorial assessment and may be externally reviewed when they contain substantial methodological analysis, new calculations or allegations requiring specialist assessment.

Timelines and records

  • The response and review due dates are stated in each individual reviewer invitation and secure portal.
  • The journal records invitations, responses, reminders, extensions, reports, decisions and recusals in the secure editorial system.
  • Authors are informed when unusual delay materially affects processing.

Questions or concerns

Use the appropriate secure route when a matter requires a documented response.