For authors
Quality, Bias & Certainty
Quality assessment depends on study type. Use validated tools, predefined acceptance criteria and independent or blinded assessment where the design requires it.
| Study or product domain | Examples of expected quality assessment |
|---|---|
| Randomized / observational clinical studies | Design-appropriate reporting and risk-of-bias assessment |
| Animal and preclinical studies | ARRIVE principles, randomization/blinding and predefined endpoints where applicable |
| Analytical methods | Validation/verification characteristics, uncertainty and system suitability |
| Pharmaceutical development and manufacturing | Critical quality attributes, process parameters, QbD/PAT or validation evidence as applicable |
| Computational / AI studies | Dataset provenance, leakage control, external validation, reproducibility and bias assessment |
| Systematic reviews | Design-appropriate risk-of-bias tools and certainty assessment such as GRADE where applicable |
Submission requirements
- State applicable standards, guidance documents, instruments or acceptance criteria and their versions.
- Report validation, verification and quality-control procedures in enough detail for evaluation.
- Explain deviations from established methods or standards.
- For evidence syntheses, provide item-level risk-of-bias judgements and supporting reasons where required by the tool.
- Discuss major sources of uncertainty, bias and limits to generalizability.