For authors

Quality, Bias & Certainty

Quality assessment depends on study type. Use validated tools, predefined acceptance criteria and independent or blinded assessment where the design requires it.

Study or product domainExamples of expected quality assessment
Randomized / observational clinical studiesDesign-appropriate reporting and risk-of-bias assessment
Animal and preclinical studiesARRIVE principles, randomization/blinding and predefined endpoints where applicable
Analytical methodsValidation/verification characteristics, uncertainty and system suitability
Pharmaceutical development and manufacturingCritical quality attributes, process parameters, QbD/PAT or validation evidence as applicable
Computational / AI studiesDataset provenance, leakage control, external validation, reproducibility and bias assessment
Systematic reviewsDesign-appropriate risk-of-bias tools and certainty assessment such as GRADE where applicable

Submission requirements